← Back to The Investigation

Part 2 of 6

Who Made the Decisions?

August 28, 2026 · By Ajai Dittmar

Part One of I Brought Receipts

Come down the rabbit hole with me.

Not the rumor rabbit hole. Not the conspiracy rabbit hole.

The public-records rabbit hole.

We're going to start with the City's own documents, put the dates in order, identify the people who had the authority to make the decisions, and separate what the records establish from what I remember firsthand.

Because I was there for part of this.

And eighteen years later, I'm finally going back through it one document at a time.

First, there were two planning phases

This distinction matters.

After the 2008 flood, Cedar Rapids moved quickly from disaster response into planning for the future of the flood-impacted neighborhoods.

The first phase began in 2008 and included development of the City's flood-management strategy and River Corridor Redevelopment Plan.

The Neighborhood Planning Process followed in 2009.

I participated in that process.

But when I started putting the City's records in chronological order, something became clear.

Significant flood-management decisions had already been made in 2008.

So let's go backward.

Who made the decisions?

The formal decision-making authority was the Cedar Rapids City Council.

On June 17, 2008, four days after the Cedar River crested, the City Council expanded the scope of the City's planning work to include the larger flood-impacted area.

According to the City's Framework Plan, the planning team was directed to address reinvestment in river-corridor neighborhoods, replacement workforce housing, enhanced flood protection, and neighborhood and development options.

The first public open house was held July 29, 2008.

The second was held September 11, 2008.

On September 24, 2008, the City Council held a four-hour work session on the flood-management strategy and River Corridor Plan.

Then comes a date worth noticing.

On October 1, 2008, the Council selected its preferred flood-management strategy for public comment and review.

Cedar Rapids flood recovery document

From the City of Cedar Rapids Framework Plan, page 5. The City's own post-flood timeline.

The third public open house was held October 16, 2008.

That's fifteen days later.

I'm not going to tell you what that means.

I'm going to show you the dates.

On November 12, 2008, the City Council approved the Framework Plan.

Cedar Rapids flood recovery document

The City's separate Timeline of Flood Protection records that the Council also approved the Preferred Flood Management System and notified the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to use it in its feasibility study.

On December 10, 2008, the Council adopted three Flood Management Areas:

Greenway. Construction. Neighborhood Revitalization.

The Council also established a policy to offer acquisition to properties within the Greenway and Construction Areas.

And then came 2009.

The Neighborhood Planning Process

According to the City's own report, the Neighborhood Planning Process began in January 2009.

Cedar Rapids neighborhood planning meeting March 21

The documented schedule was:

  • January 10, 2009: Kick-off and Goal Setting
  • January 31, 2009: Workshop 1
  • February 10, 2009: Area Meeting 1
  • February 24, 2009: Area Meeting 2
  • March 21, 2009: Workshop 2
  • March 31, 2009: Area Meeting 3
  • April 25, 2009: Workshop 3
  • May 5, 2009: Area Meeting 4
  • May 13, 2009: City Council approval of the Area Plans and supporting Action Plan

I attended those meetings. At one point, I even filled in as a scribe.

Cedar Rapids neighborhood planning scribing session

What matters here is the timeline.

The flood-management strategy and Framework Plan came first in 2008.

The Neighborhood Planning Process followed in 2009.

They were related.

They were not the same process.

The people making the decisions

The Cedar Rapids City Council serving during those initial 2008 decisions was:

  • Kay Halloran, Mayor
  • Brian Fagan, At Large
  • Tom Podzimek, At Large
  • Pat Shey, At Large
  • Kris Gulick, District 1
  • Monica Vernon, District 2
  • Jerry McGrane, District 3
  • Chuck Wieneke, District 4
  • Justin Shields, District 5
Cedar Rapids flood recovery document

Those were the elected officials who comprised the body with formal decision-making authority.

I have not located the individual roll-call votes showing how each member voted on these actions.

So I'm not assigning individual support or opposition without the record.

If the records establish it, I'll tell you.

If they don't, I'll tell you that too.

Eighteen years later

Now the chronology makes considerably more sense.

The City's preferred flood-management strategy was selected in October 2008.

The Framework Plan was approved in November 2008.

The Flood Management Areas and acquisition policy followed in December 2008.

The Neighborhood Planning Process began in January 2009.

For Article 1, we have our answer.

Who made the decisions?

The Cedar Rapids City Council had the formal authority and made the decisions that turned the City's post-flood plans into policy.

That's one question answered.

But every good rabbit hole leads to another question. 🐇

Who developed the choices the Council was given?

That's where we're going next.

The Receipts

  • City of Cedar Rapids, River Corridor Redevelopment Plan / Framework Plan
  • City of Cedar Rapids, Neighborhood Planning Process
  • City of Cedar Rapids, Timeline of Flood Protection
  • The Preferred Plan
← PreviousI Brought Receipts

Part 2 of 6